After Effects Flame Test

As I have been testing the flames in Maya I thought I would also try in After Effects to see which the group prefers. I have been playing with Trapcode Particular and think this looked the best, but I can sit with Dave and try for something better if you prefer



Using the same flame on a still in Sam's scene:



Reminder of the cartoon flame I made in Maya (which can be textured however you want) :



Let me know which you prefer and I will keep testing them this week until they are perfect :)